Sunday, November 24, 2013

Raw Materials - Mpls Local Picks 11-24


Wandering Star, Poliça, from Give You The Ghost, 2011

This track definitely benefits from headphone listening. What makes Poliça so special is their truly unique blend. Not only does Channy Leaneagh’s vocals sound like an occult prophet’s seductive chant, but of the four members two of them are drummers. You might not know it if uninitiated, but listen closely to some of the longer fills or the instrumental section before the second chorus (continuing through the chorus) where one drummer starts rolling on the snare while the other plays a syncopated hi hat part, and you’ll hear there’s eight limbs at work. The vocals have a beautiful stereo effect (accentuated by headphones). It sounds like two separate voices singing the same melody part panned hard left and right, each with a severe eighth note delay and possibly other sound sweetening effects. There is also at least one lower voice (I’m guessing Mike Noyce, who is featured on the song) underneath with a supporting harmony. Leaneagh’s executes a variety of vocal accents that quiver the soul, but the most memorable for me is in the chorus line, “It was full and I fell in love with thee.” The little tail she warbles on “thee” is perfection. 

Other elements to consider: the somber string patch, the delay on the snare, the repetition of lyrics, the modulated pizzicato strings that come in for the instrumental section and again during the outro behind the chilling vocal oohs, as well as the punchy bass tone. Actually, the bass cuts out completely for the second verse which almost makes your ear do a double take because it’s rather unexpected for the foundation to crumble so rapidly. The big drum fill makes the reentrance of the bass more dramatic and relieves the tension quite well. They use this effect again in the third chorus (a more typical spot in the arrangement) and I think it enhances the second iteration because the listener as been subconsciously conditioned at the start of the song.

Part of the reason I chose this Poliça track as opposed to a couple others I was considering (Tiff and Warrior Lords from Shulamith) is because of the music video. It definitely warrants a discussion of its own, but I’ll save that for the commentary.







Breathless, Dan Wilson, from Free Life, 2007

I had a harder time choosing a second song this week, but settled on this track from Dan Wilson. The intensity of Breathless just keeps building and each new sound introduced is a beautiful timbre and incredibly musical. The subject matter seemed well aligned with Poliça’s Wandering Star. The feeling Dan Wilson describes by singing, “and when you go you’ll leave me breathless and alone," could be imagined to be the same emotion expressed in Channy Leaneagh’s words, “I sit alone in my lonely bed and I think about the day we had and it makes me sad cause you’re gone.” Wilson’s sentiment is more of unrequited love and has a larger variety of instrumentation. His progression is a similarly expected four chords, but it really comes to life at 3:00 minutes when the chorus closes after the instrumental solo, swirling, singing “when you close the door it feels just like you took the air out of the room with you.” Something in the bass does this amazing slide up and a sweet distorted guitar comes in the left ear. Plus, there’s never enough tambourine.

Commentary:

Comment on Wandering Star

Good choice on the Poliça track - it stood out most to me on the album. This band caught my notice because of its 'trip-hop' sound - a genre whose heyday is long past, but which I always thought did a good job of being equally rhythm and melody driven, as well as effecting a chill and sometimes chilling mood. I pictured the female vocalists singing in some kind of post-apocalyptic jazz lounge. There isn't much to add to your appraisal of the song. The principle instrumental parts each seems equally well planned and executed - like good trip-hop, it hovers between mood-setting background groove and close listening, interesting melodies. Certainly the most distinctive feature of Poliça's music is the the treatment of the vocals - the delay, the hard panning, Leaneagh's merging and diverging vocal parts - it all gives a slightly, dizzy, vertiginous feeling. The entire album reminds me of that moment in intoxication, after the intial excitement of the buzz, when one first realizes that one is flagging, and indeed, the drink has gotten the better of one, when such a one looks forward to the long night ahead.

The video was interesting - perhaps because it is not clear how it relates to the content of the song. Still I think the very formalized dancing evokes the pull between the groovy rhythm and the expressive vocal melody. 

Further listening: Wandering Star, Portishead, Dummy (Too easy??)

Comment on Breathless

I tried listening to this track several times but could not find anything really interesting about it. To condemn it with faint praise, it's not bad.  

The instrumental interlude is by far the (too brief!) highlight of the song. I think this song would have more depth and impact if it weren't for the vocal part. The repetition of "breathless" made the song seem amateur, the tritely romanticist lyrics in the verses rang false to me "Hunting shadows in the dark in steaming jungles of the world", "lifting wishes to the stars", sounding like maybe a teenager's first stab at poetry. At the very least, I will say that I don't feel like Mr. Wilson actually wrote this song in the suffocating room of unrequited love, nor does it feel like there is someone out there who is the subject of this song. Lyrically it is so impersonal and forced that it sounds like he decided he wanted to write a song about unrequited love. The chorus, "But you were always pretty reckless with your love..." at least drops the faux-poetry and resorts to a more sincere sounding colloquial, conversational tone. But either way, I just can't get over my inability to believe a word he's saying.  I can't get past my feeling that Mr. Wilson didn't make any interesting decisions in writing and recording this. I think this is probably the kind of music that is good to see live on a Saturday night, but I think when it has to compete with all the digital concerts available at the tap of a finger it falls a bit flat.

I had a hard time finding a similar song in my repetoire - I have almost nothing of the singer/songwriter-at-a- clean-piano sound. So I threw something up in a similar spirit, I think, and, I do believe, MPLS locals.

Further listening: Doves & Stones, Mark Olson & Gary Louris, Ready for the Flood

No comments:

Post a Comment