Wednesday, November 6, 2013
Raw Materials - Seasoned and Fresh 11-08
Which Will, Nick Drake, from Pink Moon, 1972
This song has grown on me in a haunting way. The simple vocal melody floating on top of a rather complex acoustic guitar lick makes for a perfect pairing. The words immediately resonate a sympathy for the subjective experience and beckons the individual to decide "which will you dance for", "which will you love the best".
Fairweather Friends, Queens Of The Stone Age, from ...Like Clockwork, 2013
The unusual arrangement of this song takes you on an epic rock roller coaster. The subtle use of piano and the wailing guitar riff leading up to the chorus, builds excitedly to the anticipated vocal line, "what's it going to take to get you back in bed". The lyrics are borderline too simplistic, but are well integrated into the music rhythmically. The short choral intro is a nice touch...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


Which Will: I can't say anything bad about Nick Drake. I feel he can do no wrong - none of his songs seem superfluous or filler, and within the songs themselves, they seem to know when to stop (most between 2 and 3 minutes - more like a punk rock single than a singer songwriter!). I'd say that Pink Moon's virtue is it's restraint - Drake errs on the side of giving us too little rather than giving us too much. I think the effect is that we are always a bit surprised when the song is over; but with a classical sense of proportion, the songs say what they need to say and no more, and then depart. In a way, they are so subtle that they leave no trace - but are maybe the melodies and phrases that come back to haunt you later, unexpected.
ReplyDeleteIt is hard to say what exactly it is that makes these songs so distinct among acoustic/vocalist format songs. Surely part of it is the breathy, gentle vocals - sometimes they sound sadly resigned, sometimes they sound calmly hopeful. Also, the lyrical vocabulary is quite simple, essential:
"Which will you...", beginning 14 of the 20 lines of the song, offers a choice to the audience, but in each case, the terms are left highly unspecified - in fact, each line really just asks, which of the (unspecified) alternatives will you choose, which is synonymous with "go for", "love", "choose from" "answer", "call", "take for", and finally, "love the best". These synonyms for choosing become more metaphorical as the song goes on - "dance for", "shine" "hope for".
All we really know about this choice is that is for "one and all" - it is the existential choice (ie, to be condemned to choose oneself, each choice annihilating all the unchosen possibilities), but drained of all it's angst. The Choice here, which in the west is often made the defining character of being human, is celebrated, not feared - even the fact that Drake himself will be rejected by this choice ("If you won't take me") is passed over without so much as a flinch from the encouraging vocals or from the bounding guitar strum. Interestingly enough, the only concrete noun that shows up in the song are "the stars above", which have often in contrast been symbols of fate, rather than choice. But here, Drake has the audience choosing from amongst the stars - a clever inversion.
The final thing to say about the distinctness of this song would be of course, the guitar part itself - half picked, half strummed, and certainly just as engaging as the vocals in vying for our attention. In contrast to the vocals, the guitar is very dense - it seems to be able to convey the entire mood of the song and to tell a story: the guitar seeming meticulously composed yet playfully unpredictable, which in a way, makes a further statement about the choice.
I don't know how much of this song can be 'mined' for its materials - simply because it all wears the virtuosity of Nick Drake, but it certainly is a great track.
Fair Weather Friends: I can't say that I much cared for this song as a whole - it had an operatic-rock in the vocal and lead guitar melodies, which always seem so artificially dramatic to me; I feel like the form and content should in some manner enhance each other, but I don't think the content (gossip/drugs/unrequited love leaving us in need) merits the "epic" scale of the instrumentation. It sounds to me a lot like Muse. It also seems like a lot of old "alt rock" tricks and not really anything new/interesting going on. In contrast to the Drake or Beach House, I feel like the choice of adding keys is an afterthought - adding more because MORE is how you finish a song (Pink Moon being the best example I can think of to falsify that claim!). Also, the lyrics and symbolism are mostly transparent (the whole sun/rain trope), or cliche (it ain't so long before the dawn) and all of it comes across as tired and insincere, mostly because the instrumentation choices are so perfunctory (the droning guitars, the "epic" middle lead) that it's hard to feel that they are expressive of genuine emotions, rather than old dogs up to their old tricks. I feel like the guitar/drums could background any song - whatever lyrics they happened to write over them. I was surprised to read the lyrics after hearing the song. I don't know what mood I would be in when I would turn to a song like this for relief; it does manage to convey a sense of a hurt jealousy and it's resultant anger, but I don't tend to indulge vengefulness or anger in my music choices. Given unrequited love, I would listen to "I know it's Over" by the Smiths, or "Give Out", by Sharon Van Etten, where the only anger that informs the lyrics has long been turned into self-reproach and resignation. But that isn't really a critical comment, more of a personal preference. Still, I find it hard to identify with either the perspective of the singer or the audience, which is not the case with the other three tracks this week.
ReplyDeleteWhat I do like about the song - I do like the vocal melody as such - even if it has a operatic range to it. Same with the guitar riff. (I think it's when the whole ensemble gets together - the drums, the vocal content, the keys, the droning guitars - that i lose interest). I also like that the song is actually not about friendship at all, but about trying to get an ex back in the sack; the fairweather friends of the title are actually "gossip, drugs, and snakes" - so the moral, slightly veiled but not buried very deep, is that the things we turn to when we're heartbroken will (also) leave us when we need them most; It is likely that gossip and drugs are what split the two up in the as well as what held them together while they were together. There is some unearthing to do with the rain/fairweather trope - that when she left, it was rain, therefore, fairweather, drugs and gossip, were there before she left him, and now they have left him, along with her, and the fair weather. It leaves it strange that at the end he is praying for rain - since presumably this means he's praying that she doesn't come back; But this conflict between wanting and not wanting someone back is not very difficult to understand. Other lines like, "What's it going to take/To get you back in bed?", are so literal they leave nothing to discuss. But the content doesn't beg to be decoded much.
Responsive Listening:
(1) To: Which Will: It's Hard to Get Around the Wind, Alex Turner, The Submarine Soundtrack (Breathy Vocals o'er Acoustic Guitars, singin' 'bout love and life)
(2) To Fairweather Friends: I Lost You, The Walkmen, from You & Me (Saying Goodbye to love, before the dawn; on a roller coaster)